The feedback on Idaho's Unit 49 reflects a nuanced picture for hunters, emphasizing the importance of preparation and realistic expectations. The severe winter kill in 2016-2017 significantly reduced deer populations, a fact corroborated by multiple year-long hunters, although elk seem to have fared better and were more resilient due to their dietary flexibility. Archery tags are available over-the-counter but in limited quantities, necessitating early purchase in December. Reports suggest collaborative and solo hunters found success, especially for elk, by targeting varied terrain and deploying strategic scouting, highlighting the utility of mules and horses for deeper access into the rugged country. Aspiring hunters should focus on adapting to fluctuating game populations and leveraging shared experiences, despite challenges, to enhance their hunts in this striking but challenging unit.