The discussion around Unit 16A in New Mexico offers valuable insights into both practical logistics and hunting strategies. Hunters can generally expect a refund on the cost difference if they draw a less expensive tag as a second or third choice. Elk populations in 16A are notably impacted by water availability, with dry conditions potentially hindering antler growth. Several hunters provide advice to scout different elevations and terrain types, noting that elk may be found in both high and low areas throughout the day. As specific challenges such as wolf presence and road conditions arise, the community's shared experiences help other hunters prepare for the varied dynamics of hunting in this competitive and highly sought-after unit.
| species | general Size | trophy potential |
|---|---|---|
| Mule Deer | 140"-160" | 160"+ |
| Elk | 320"-350" | 370"+ |
| Antelope | 70"-80" | 80"+ |
High
Low
This is one of the best elk units in New Mexico and many large bulls have come out of here. tags are limited and draw odds are steep but lucky hunters will be in for an incredible hunt. Deer and antelope populations are also decent within this area and great hunting opportunities can be found for them.
Some huge elk have come from this unit. Mule deer grow big, but hunter success is low and mature bucks are rare. Mule deer from this area have qualified for all-time B&C records.
Hunters who have spent time in the high altitudes of Colorado or the broken, steep terrain in Utah, Wyoming or Idaho would consider Unit 16A as having mild, easy-to-hunt terrain. Much of it is fairly open with many big meadows that draw elk into the open.
A maze of dirt roads reach into almost every canyon and on every major ridge and it is hard to get more than two miles from a road. Major interior roads include Bear Wallow Road off State Highway 159, Deep Creek Ranch Road off US 180, State Route 145 and several roads off Highway 12.
Forests from about 7,000 feet and higher are composed of several species of trees, including ponderosa pine, several kinds of junipers, including alligator juniper, pinyon pine, blue spruce, Douglas fir and quaking aspen. Terrain below 7,000 feet is mostly open brush and grasslands with expanses of thinly scattered junipers and pinyons.
Lodging options include Hidden Springs Inn in Reserve, Frisco Lodging Co. & RV Park in Reserve and Silver Creek Inn in Mogollon. The Gila National Forest maintains improved and primitive campsites. Camping is allowed in the Gila National Forest outside campgrounds.
Roughly 644 square miles
96.9% public land
Elevations range from about 5,000-9,938 feet