Hunters discussing Idaho's Unit 58 highlight the unit's challenging yet rewarding terrain, emphasizing the need for proper preparation and physical fitness to navigate its rugged landscape. Many commenters suggest scouting the area early in the season to familiarize with game movements and identify optimal hunting spots. Several experienced hunters note that draw odds can be competitive, but patience and persistence often lead to successful hunts, particularly for elk. Overall, the sentiment is that while Unit 58 may require effort and strategy, it offers a worthwhile hunting experience for those ready to tackle its demands.